The Locals Email About Everything St Augustine

Sent twice a week, this 5 minute email will give you all the insights on news, events and the real estate market

St. Augustine Real Estate : Buy vs Rent

Nestled on the northeastern coast of Florida, St. Augustine is not just America’s oldest city but a hotspot for residential and vacation opportunities. The real estate landscape here offers an array of options, serving both homeowners and renters. The crucial question we often face is: Should we buy or rent in St. Augustine? This blog aims to be your comprehensive guide to understanding the St. Augustine Real Estate market and helping you make an informed decision.

1. The St. Augustine Real Estate Landscape


General Market Trends

Median Home Prices
Over the last few years, the median home prices in St. Augustine have seen a steady increase. This trend suggests a promising future for those looking to invest in real estate.

Types of Available Properties
From charming condos and apartments to single-family homes, St. Augustine offers a property type for every buyer or renter.

Neighborhoods and Their Characteristics
St. Augustine neighborhoods like Lincolnville and Davis Shores are popular for their community spirit and local amenities. Each locality has its unique charm and advantages.

Factors Affecting the Market


The economic vibrancy in St. Augustine plays a key role in shaping its real estate market.

Job Market
With an emerging job market in tourism, healthcare, and education, the city presents strong career prospects for residents.

The city’s rich history and tourist attractions make it an evergreen destination, positively affecting property values.

Infrastructure Development
Upcoming infrastructure projects are another driving factor behind the booming real estate in St. Augustine.

2. The Case for Buying Real Estate


Long-Term Investment


Property Value Appreciation
Long-term investment in St. Augustine Real Estate generally promises appreciating property values, offering a secure financial future.

Equity Building
Buying a home means building equity over time, as opposed to renting where your money goes into someone else’s pocket.

Tax Benefits
Homeownership in St. Augustine comes with substantial tax advantages like property tax deductions.

Ownership Perks


Freedom to Customize
Owning a home provides you the freedom to make modifications and truly make it your own.

No Landlord Rules
Forget about restrictive landlord rules; you’re the boss in your own home.

Sense of Community Belonging
Ownership often brings a sense of community belonging that is less commonly found in rental scenarios.

Financing Options


Mortgage Rates
Current mortgage rates in St. Augustine are relatively favorable, especially for first-time homeowners.

First-Time Homeowner Programs
Various programs are available that offer down payment assistance and lower mortgage rates for first-time buyers.

3. The Case for Renting in St. Augustine




Easier to Move
Renting offers the flexibility of moving without the burden of selling a property first.

No Long-Term Commitment
Renting is suitable for those who are not yet ready to commit to a long-term investment.

Lower Upfront Costs


No Down Payment
Renting eliminates the need for a hefty down payment, making it easier to move in.

No Maintenance Costs
Renters generally don’t have to worry about maintenance costs, as they are usually covered by the landlord.

Amenities and Lifestyle


Access to Pools, Gyms, Etc.
Many renting communities offer access to amenities like pools, gyms, and clubhouses.

More Temporary, Tourist-Like Lifestyle
Renting in St. Augustine allows for a lifestyle that is more flexible and oriented toward short-term stays.

4. What to Consider Before Making a Decision


Financial Standing


Current Income
Consider your income and job stability before diving into buying or renting.

Credit Score
A good credit score is crucial for securing a mortgage at favorable terms.

Future Financial Goals
Your long-term financial aspirations should significantly influence your decision to buy or rent.

Lifestyle Needs


Size of Family
Your family size and needs should dictate the type of property you should aim for.

Job Security
If your job situation is unstable, renting may be a safer option.

Market Timing


Seasonal Price Fluctuations
Be aware of seasonal price fluctuation in St. Augustine’s real estate market.

Current Mortgage Rates and Renting Costs
Always keep an eye on the mortgage rates and rental costs in St. Augustine before making a decision.


Both buying and renting in St. Augustine come with their own sets of advantages and drawbacks. Your personal circumstances, financial standing, and future plans will play a crucial role in shaping your decision. This blog aims to serve as a comprehensive guide for anyone considering buying or renting in St. Augustine. Analyze, plan, and take the step that suits you best.

The Locals Email About Everything St Augustine

Sent twice a week, this 5 minute email will give you all the insights on news, events and the real estate market

Real Estate Done Right

We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.

Living in St Augustine

[email protected]


Open today 09:00 am – 07:00 pm

Contact Us

If you want to learn more, reach out below!